Thread:King Dragonhoff/@comment-24859896-20160320050605/@comment-24859896-20160321010056

I understand it's the job of staff to make decisions, I've been staff on Clash of Clans Wikia since 2012. I think I know a thing or two about this. Let me discuss one thing by one person at a time, to be more organized.

@Dragon Rainbow - Updating page: As I said above, this page would not need updating. It may require updating rarely once more and more cards are added, but yet still keeping the page nice and tidy. With the category page, of course it does it automatically, but it will just add onto a completely separate, and unnecessary page which you need to scroll down and click to just to see those extra cards. I'll regard that later.

@Dragon Rainbow - Voting by others: Isn't that essentially what you guys are? You guys don't come here all the time randomly to get info you already know, you've been playing the game before the global release. I understand you guys are staff and do have the power to fight me and completely demolish my idea, however again you aren't the only ones. You all are people who know the game inside and out, and there are only a select few of you. You don't visit here as newbies looking for info on cards you don't even know the name of. Some may come here, click on the category page, and not see their card because it's on a separate page they don't even know how to get to. Anyways, I'll address that in another answer but you get my point. You need to allow those people to have a chance in voting, even if people who are veterans are voting. It is still their Wikia, and they deserve a chance to have a say in what they want to see, it's not all about what you want, really. Again, I've been a staff member for almost 4 years, I used to make executive decisions without the community knowing, but when I opened up voting on what they wanted, they were thrilled I allowed them to vote on such simple things; even a card page. You need to open up the decisions to the community, even if they aren't newbies.

@Dragon Rainbow - Making executive decisions based on opinion: I dressed a little of this above, so this answer won't be as long. You stated above the following. "We know the wiki good and if we think we can leave it as it is, then I guess it is the best choice." Who is it to say that you know everything, that you know "the best choice?" God didn't come down to earth and give you the knowledge to know the best choice for a Wikia just because you created a Wikia, or for those promoted to staff. You have no clue what is the best choice for a Wikia, you have the power to choose something yourself, but that doesn't mean it's the best choice for the community.

@King Dragonhoff - Category page design: Just because it is part of a category doesn't mean it has to be on a category page. What I don't understand is how you say this about my idea, however you guys create a page with the same concept. All in one category, however combining onto one page. What I am talking about is the Arenas page. Arena's are all completely separate, different layout, different cards unlocked, all fall under a category of "Arena." However, you combine these different categories onto a single article page when you easily could have made a single page on each Arena. Back to what I was originally saying, you don't have to strictly keep a category page even though they all fall under a category. Everything falls under a category, yet you put a block on cards? Is there a difference that cards don't deserve their own combined page? I don't see the logic. What does it hurt to add a more well-thought out page that has more benefits than the other?

Sorry for my long reply, but I do have quite a bit of time to fight this. And also what does it hurt to bring it to the community who visits this more than us? Are you afraid your idea will lose? If you are all so sure your idea is "the best choice" why are you not taking it to battle knowing you'll win. I find it because you aren't sure the outcome of it will be. Bring it to the community with a poll, and I will end this argument, win or lose.